Located at 5591 N Croatan Hwy in Southern Shores, NC, Cosmo's Pizzeria Southern Shores At The Market Place is a standout destination for pizza lovers on the Outer Banks. This laid-back eatery delivers a consistently satisfying experience with its bold flavors, generous portions, and warm, welcoming atmosphere.
At the heart of Cosmo's appeal is its pizza-crafted with hand-tossed dough, a signature sauce that balances tangy and sweet notes, and cheese that's perfectly melted and layered for that classic New York-style taste. The crust is crisp on the edges yet remains soft and chewy in the center, offering a satisfying texture in every bite. Whether you’re grabbing a single slice or a full pie, the quality is unmistakable.
Beyond the pizza, Cosmo’s also excels with its calzones and sandwiches. The calzones are known for their unreal size and flavor, packed with rich fillings and baked to perfection. Sandwich lovers will appreciate the impressive portions and hearty flavors, making it a great stop for a casual yet filling meal. Don’t be surprised if you need a to-go box-Cosmo's doesn't hold back on serving size.
Adding to the experience is the open kitchen vibe, where diners can watch the skilled team hand-tossing dough right before their eyes. This element not only enhances the authenticity but also connects guests to the craftsmanship behind each order.
The staff at Cosmo’s contribute to its charm, creating a friendly and relaxed setting where locals and visitors alike feel at home. Whether you’re a New Yorker missing your hometown slice or a first-time guest exploring the Outer Banks, Cosmo's delivers on taste and hospitality. Ideal for quick lunches, group dinners, or satisfying your pizza cravings anytime, Cosmo’s Pizzeria Southern Shores is a place where classic flavors meet generous hospitality in every dish.
Bottled Water
Imported Mexican Soda
Can
Fountain
Additions to Tacos
cheese, sour cream, guacamole, rice
Additions to Burritos
cheese, sour cream, guacamole, rice
Pico de Gallo
Tamale
Been coming here for like 13 years now, the food is always fantastic and so consistant you always can count on your favorite dishes tasting as good as they did the first time you had them and the staff are the friendliest people.
I get that everyone has their opinion of what food should taste like, but the folks on here calling is trash and horrible are in my opinion incorrect. I’ve had nothing but good food and great service!! Everything on the menu affordable, which is a testament to the owner’s connection to the people they serve! Definitely a great spot to pick up some lunch!
Excellent carne asada burrito. Huge and tasty.
I'm from San diego and have been hunting a great taco shop. This is the place! The food was amazing, service was great and they are super fast!
Visiting Oregon, found this little spot in west linn, Very good tacos & burritos, didn’t have the chance to take pic of the burrito but got some of the pastor tacos,